Motor Comparison Table

[Benh]

Hi - I am either looking for a comparison chart for motors or to put it together (without having to buy every motor out there!). Without going into great detail on sintered, not sintered, sensored, not sensored etc just a rough guide of power really for motor comparisons.
Once it's done, I'll pop it on excel and upload it then it can be updated with other manufacturers as we go?

For Example

Novak 3.5 = LRP??? = MAMBA? = Brushed Turn?
Novak 4.5 = LRP??? = MAMBA? = Brushed Turn?
Novak 5.5 = LRP??? = MAMBA? = Brushed Turn?
Novak 6.5 = LRP??? = MAMBA? = Brushed Turn?
Novak 7.5 = LRP??? = MAMBA? = Brushed Turn?
Novak 8.5 = LRP??? = MAMBA? = Brushed Turn?

Maybe this has already been covered, but I think it will be a great help to new members of clubs.

Many thanks

[zaquiz]

- FEIGAO=PEAK RACING=ORIOM=VENOM=TRINITY
* 3.5 = 10.500 rpm/v, max 7.4v (77.700 rpm), XXX Watios
* 4.5 = 8.900 rpm/v, max 7.4v (65.860 rpm), XXX Watios
* 5.5 = 7.300 rpm/v, max 7.4v (54.020 rpm), XXX Watios
* 6.5 = 6.500 rpm/v, max 7.4v (48.100 rpm), XXX Watios
* 7.5 = 6.000 rpm/v, max 7.4v (44.400 rpm), XXX Watios
* 8.5 = 5.200 rpm/v, max 7.4v (38.480 rpm), XXX Watios
* 9.5 = 4.400 rpm/v, max 7.4v (32.560 rpm), XXX Watios
* 10.5 = 4.200 rpm/v, max 7.4v (31.080 rpm), XXX Watios
* 13.5 = 3.600 rpm/v, max 7.4v (26.640 rpm), XXX Watios
* 18.5 = 2.700 rpm/v, max 7.4v (19.980 rpm), XXX Watios

- LRP o NOSRAM
* Vector X11-3.0 = 11.400 rpm/v, max 7.4v (84.360 rpm), 745 Watios
* Vector X11-3.5 = 9.800 rpm/v, max 7.4v (72.520 rpm), 653 Watios
* Vector LRP 4.0 = 8.600 rpm/v, max 7.2v (61.920 rpm), 581 Watios
* Vector X11-4.5 = 7.800 rpm/v, max 7.4v (57.720 rpm), 528 Watios
* Vector X11-5.5 = 8.100 rpm/v, max 7.4v (59.940 rpm), 393 Watios
* Vector X11-6.5 = 6.900 rpm/v, max 7.4v (51.060 rpm), 332 Watios
* Vector X11-7.5 = 5.900 rpm/v, max 7.4v (43.660 rpm), 291 Watios
* Vector X11-8.5 = 4.100 rpm/v, max 7.4v (30.340 rpm), 284 Watios
-------- Serie STOCK ----------
* Vector X11-8.5 =
* Vector X11-9.5 =
* Vector X11-10.5 =
* Vector X11-13.5 =
* Vector X11-17.5 =
* Vector X11-21.5 =
---------- Serie Eraser -----------
* Vector Eraser 09.5 = 4.700 rpm/v, max 7.2v (33.840 rpm), 200 Watios
* Vector Eraser 10.5 = 4.100 rpm/v, max 7.2v (29.520 rpm), 180 Watios
* Vector Eraser 13.5 = 3.100 rpm/v, max 7.2v (22.320 rpm), 130 Watios
* Vector Eraser 15.5 = 2.800 rpm/v, max 7.2v (20.160 rpm), 130 Watios


- MAMBA
* 4600 = 4600 rpm/v, max 11.1v (51.060 rpm)
* 5700 = 5700 rpm/v, max 11.1v (63.270 rpm)
* 6900 = 6900 rpm/v, max 7.4v (51.060 rpm)
* 7700 = 7700 rpm/v, max 7,4v (56.980 rpm)


- NOVAK
* 7.5L = 5400 rpm/v, max 7.4V (39960 rpm). 250 W
* 6.5L = 5900 rpm/v. max 7.4V (43660 rpm). 315 W
* 5.5L = 6800 rpm/v. max 7.4V (50320 rpm). 350 W
* 4.5L = 8200 rpm/v. max 7.4V (60680 rpm). 413 W
* 3.5L = 10300 rpm/v. max 7.4V (76220 rpm). 431W
------------
* 7.5R = 5.800 rpm/v, max 7.4v (42.920 rpm), 275 Watios
* 6.5R = 6.400 rpm/v, max 7.4v (47.360 rpm), 340 Watios
* 5.5R = 7.400 rpm/v, max 7.4v (54.760 rpm), 380 Watios
* 4.5R = 9.000 rpm/v, max 7.4v (66.600 rpm), 415 Watios
* 3.5R = 10.500 rpm/v, max 7.4v (77.700 rpm), 490 Watios
-------------
* SS_8.5/SS5800 = 5.000 rpm/v, max 8.4v (42.000 rpm), 225 Watios
* SS10.5 = 4.200 rpm/v, max 8.4v (35.280 rpm), 235 Watios
* SS13.5 = 3.300 rpm/v, max 8.4v (27.720 rpm), 195 Watios
* SS17.5 = 2.200 rpm/v, max 8.4v (18.480 rpm), 130 Watios
* SS20.5 = 1.800 rpm/v, max 8.4v (15.120 rpm), 085 Watios
--------------
* CRAWLER 18.5 = 2700 rpm/v, MAX 8.4v (22.680 RPM), 119W
* Crawler 21.5 = 1800 rpm/v, MAX 8.4v ( 15.120 rpm), 85W


- SPEED PASSION
* 2.5 = 13800 rpm/v, max 7.4v (102.120 rpm), 580 Watios
* 3.5 = 12100 rpm/v, max 7.4v (89.540 rpm), 500 Watios
* 4.0 = 11500 rpm/v, max 8.4v (96.600 rpm), 460 Watios
* 4.5 = 10800 rpm/v, max 7.4v (79.920 rpm), 429 Watios
* 5.5 = 7500 rpm/v, max 16.8v (126.000 rpm), 650 Watios ******* RECORD ABSOLUTO ********
* 6.5 = 6800 rpm/v, max 16.8v (114.240 rpm), 550 Watios
* 7.5 = 6000 rpm/v, max 16.8v (100.800 rpm), 450 Watios
* 8.5 = 5300 rpm/v, max 16.8v (89.040 rpm), 350 Watios


- TEKIN
* Redline 290-2.0T = 9.000 rpm/v, max 7.4v (66.600 rpm), xx Watios
* Redline 278-2.5T = 7.800 rpm/v, max 7.4v (57.720 rpm), xx Watios
* Redline 268-2.5T = 6.800 rpm/v, max 7.4v (50.320 rpm), xx Watios
* Redline 362-3.0T = 6.200 rpm/v, max 7.4v (45.880 rpm), xx Watios
* Redline 358-3.5T = 5.800 rpm/v, max 7.4v (42.920 rpm), xx Watios
* Redline 448-4.0T = 4.800 rpm/v, max 7.4v (35.520 rpm), xx Watios
* Redline 537-5.0T = 3.700 rpm/v, max 7.4v (27.380 rpm), xx Watios
* Redline 632-6.0T = 3.200 rpm/v, max 7.4v (23.680 rpm), xx Watios
--------------------
* FXR Crawler 55T =
--------------------
* Redline Sensored 2.5 =
* Redline Sensored 3.5 =
* Redline Sensored 4.5 =
* Redline Sensored 5.5 =
* Redline Sensored 6.5 =
* Redline Sensored 7.5 =
* Redline Sensored 8.5 =
* Redline Sensored 9.5 =
* Redline Sensored 10.5 =
* Redline Sensored 13.5 =
* Redline Sensored 17.5 =
* Redline Sensored 21.5 =

[Benh]

Wow. ¡Qué respuesta fantástica. Muchas gracias. Tiene detalles de cepillado motores?

[Richard Lowe]

- SPEED PASSION
*2.5 = 13800 rpm/v, max 7.4v (102.120 rpm), 580 Watios

Holy crap
Does anyone have a 6 tooth pinion...

For the record the X11 ratings between 5.5 - 7.5 are for the old 14mm bonded rotor.

:::EDIT:::
The specs for the sintered Nosram/LRP XTEC's are...
Vector X11 5.5 = 6200 rpm/v, max 7.4v (44.640 rpm), 433 Watt(ios!)
Vector X11 6.5 = 5250 rpm/v, max 7.4v (37.800 rpm), 368 Watt(ios!)
Vector X11 7.5 = 4600 rpm/v, max 7.4v (33.120 rpm), 318 Watt(ios!)

All with the standard 14mm rotor.

For 2wd I really like the 7.5 with the optional 12.5mm rotor, 4wd is either the 5.5 or 6.5 with the optional 13mm rotor

[Benh]

Just uploaded what we have to the club webiste to check on the feedback. If I get shot down in flames, I'll quitely retreat into silence. If a more positive response, I'll put what we have on here to check feedback and updates.

[Benh]

This is what's together so far - Thank you zaquiz! If anybody has anything they would like to add please feel free and update sheet 1 (motor tab sheet) - and post on here

I can't upload an excel sheet - so here's a link instead.

http://gallery.myff.org/gallery/2677...ison+Table.xls

[Benh]

Originally Posted by Richard Lowe

:::EDIT:::
The specs for the sintered Nosram/LRP XTEC's are...
Vector X11 5.5 = 6200 rpm/v, max 7.4v (44.640 rpm), 433 Watt(ios!)
Vector X11 6.5 = 5250 rpm/v, max 7.4v (37.800 rpm), 368 Watt(ios!)
Vector X11 7.5 = 4600 rpm/v, max 7.4v (33.120 rpm), 318 Watt(ios!)

All with the standard 14mm rotor.

For 2wd I really like the 7.5 with the optional 12.5mm rotor, 4wd is either the 5.5 or 6.5 with the optional 13mm rotor

Just seen the edit and updated our sheet. Many thanks.

[Billy]

How come the sintered rotors rev lower than the bonded ones? Does this mean that the bonded are faster or that the Watios make the difference due to the different gear ratio to be used?

The specs for the sintered Nosram/LRP XTEC's are...
Vector X11 5.5 = 6200 rpm/v, max 7.4v (44.640 rpm), 433 Watt(ios!)

Bonded
Vector X11-5.5 = 8.100 rpm/v, max 7.4v (59.940 rpm), 393 Watios