Not all clubs are BRCA affiliated, just thought I'd throw that one into the mix.
As for Josh, I think he comes across really well - if the club chooses to ban him that's up to them, I'm sure they also ban people charging at 6amps or swearing or deliberately wrecking their own cars. Saying they are wrong isn't really appropriate since it's already done and won't help Josh at all.
I'm not sure if Josh is actually banned from the BRCA but that sounds well-OTT to me - but that's MY opinion and since I'm closing the thread now no one can argue with me