oOple.com Forums

oOple.com Forums (http://www.oople.com/forums/index.php)
-   KYOSHO (http://www.oople.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=10)
-   -   Kyosho Big bore tapered pistons (http://www.oople.com/forums/showthread.php?t=77345)

sime46 30-03-2012 07:27 PM

Small bores rule.

SimonW 30-03-2012 08:03 PM

I've finally decided that 2x1.3 and 2x1.4 per piston is what i will use in my vega front and rear. After filling 1 of the holes in the stock 5x1.3 and not changing the oil weight a quick bench test felt a little too stiff ( pack) and too slow but only just for my taste, on the track the car was alot better than with 5 holes. Past experiences with shocks i thought the 4x1.4 will be close but a little soft so i went for the mid point. HTH's

RogerM 31-03-2012 12:10 PM

Right guys, I am still not in the position where I can say that this is definitively the best setup for either car but we have now put something like 30 hours running (our poor cars would be destroyed by now if any other brand) and 75 hours at the track tinkeing and have settled on the following as the starting base setups for each ... although this may evolve over the next few weeks as we get more and more feedback from other drivers. We have had 28 different pistons to work through and drained about 12 bottles of shock oil between up even being methodical about our testing order. All testing has been done against the clock and so isn't what feels fast it is what is fast (for us at least).


2wd (Scorpion & VEGA tested, sadly no MCS available but I can't imagine it to be far off ...)

4x1.40 front (35wt AE oil as a starting point and tune from there, remember 2.5wt is a big step on the big bores), X-gear Gold springs with staggered ribs / minispikes, Reds with minipins. That is shocks out on wishbone and mid on original tower
For those running Losi springs that is Orange
4x1.45 rear (30wt, 32.5 if you like a livelier rear end) and X-gear red or Yellow springs depending on how much rear roll you like form the car.
For those running Losi springs that is Pink.
That is shocks inside on wishbone and middle on Scorpion stinger tower, 1 in from outside on Vega.

Because the stock RB5 runs much more inclined rear shocks than the mid motor cars I would expect that you will be wanting to reduce pistons 4x1.4 and maybe even then still go up 2.5wt in the oil. Sadly we have not had the opportunity to do much testing with a rear motored car.

I tried 3,4,5 & 6 hole combinations but to get the front end geometry to really work and feel alive, responsive & stable at the same time you need to have a little bit more instantaneous roll than you can get with 5 or 6 hole pistons but not as much as 3 hole pistons give you.
I hate to think how many combinations we put across the cars to arrive here but each time we moved from the 4x1.40 fronts we found ourselves back there a few logical tuning steps later. The rear sort of followed the progression of the front end tuning with the key objective being balance, that said we worked all around the various combinations in that region and kept coming back to the 4x1.45.


With the FS2-sp it was just as mammoth task but at least we had the 5x1.3/5x1.4 setup to use as a base line from last season and the 4x1.2/6x1.2 setup we settled on for the big jump strewn indoor carpet tracks.

After much work it became apparent that the front and rear of the FS2 are so superbly balanced that you didn't have to push one far away from the sweet spot before it started to show up very apparent weaknesses in the setup. That is great because you can get almost instant validation to a change at one end of the car.

Up until yesterday evening I would have said that I was happy with the setup as we finished with it a couple of weeks ago but Nick sent me through some extra pistons to try based on the requests & feedback I'd given him earlier in the week. Cutting a long story short a change of front pistons highlighted that we were too soft at the rear, a couple of hours tuning time later and we had a car that was fast, confidence inspiring and a pure joy to drive ... even let you get away with the odd wheel on a track marker type error at full speed without getting unsettled.

Front 5x1.2/35-37.5wt AE oil with a Losi Green spring (mid hole on front wishbone), 3rd in on tower
Rear 5x1.35/30wt AE oil X-gear red or yellow rear spring (or Losi Pink which is similar to X-gear yellow) inside on LAW43 and middle on tower.

Now I am convinced by the above setup but there were only two of us at the track last night testing and light was failing so I have nobody else to get an opinion from other than what they saw. The comments I got back where that the car looked to be stable and stayed relatively flat throughout the lap and it was certainly quick on the clock too.
It is great over the bumps (with ride height set 18 to 19 ... use 19-20 if track is REALLY rough) and just holds it's line no matter what the surface throws at it.
Be warned, this setup generates a LOT of steering and as such you might find its a bit of a handful until you get used to it then you will love the fact that it will turn inside any other 4wd car out there, nothing will be sneaking up the inside of you in a final for sure :)
If it is too much all that should be required to calm the nose a little is to stand the front shocks up one hole and/or go up 2.5wt in front oil (try all combinations to find what suits your driving style).
I know I have said this repeatedly but it still holds true, IMHO the Lazer FS platform is as close to perfection as a 4wd car can be.


As I say work is still continuing but I believe that both of the above setups will give very good starting points for your own individual tuning.

I hope to be writing a full breakdown of the trials very soon and hopefully there will be a full on article covering damper tuning on oOple soon ;)

Gayo 31-03-2012 12:42 PM

:thumbsup::woot::thumbsup::woot::thumbsup:

Quote:

We have had 28 different pistons to work through and drained about 12 bottles of shock oil
Now that is nuts :lol:

I will try your findings ASAP, now where is Nick?:lol:

njc11 31-03-2012 01:52 PM

Sounds good Roger... :thumbsup:

Im racing tomorrw, just MCS though, so may if i have time try your shock settings!

:thumbsup:

RogerM 31-03-2012 02:47 PM

Nick,

been trying to find time to give you a call all this week but life has been chaotic .... not helped by all the testing LOL. Will try to get hold of you tonight buddy.

RogerM 31-03-2012 02:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gayo (Post 638644)
:thumbsup::woot::thumbsup::woot::thumbsup:



Now that is nuts :lol:

I will try your findings ASAP, now where is Nick?:lol:

Well the other options were either guessing or not bothering at all .....

To my mind you either do a job properly or not at all :thumbsup:

Now, remember that I am not on the pace of Kev Lee's etc. BUT running those settings on the 2wd last weekend I was able to monster all other cars through the rough stuff and wasn't loosing out anywhere on the infield sections and my times through the runs were very consistent and faster than those I am normally racing for places. I do however need to remind myself that no run is improved by over driving the first lap .... my ability to stick it on it's roof on the out lap was the only thing more consistent than the other lap times :woot:

Nick 12-04-2012 12:16 PM

Hi just to say thanks for the orders and the have all been posted :thumbsup: Also if anyone need any at the national i will have some with me! See you all at the weekend.

RogerM 13-04-2012 06:55 AM

Hi guys, just a quick update. I've had the week off work and have made it out a couple of times to try some more stuff.
The short story is that I keep coming back to the shock setups listed above, there are other combinations that make the cars feel easier to drive but all seem either slower or less consistent against the clock.

I have found with the above setups all that I am changing for different tracks / conditions are;

Inner ball stud spacing (typically starting at 1mm both ends on the Lazer, 5mm [use the ball studs with the 2mm shoulder to prevent them pulling out] front & 2mm rear on the 2wd)

Upper shock mounting position (in when more roll needed, out when less wanted)

front hub height (run the front AXLE low for buckets full of front end bite, axles up if you want to calm the car down) ... this is a powerful tool, especially on the FS2!



Just to clarify the rear shock tower position on the 2wd; they are mounted at distance apart that is equivalent to the width between the middle holes on the Lazer rear tower.


Hopefully that will help some of you ... lets put the small bores to bed for good ;)

Nick 19-04-2012 06:01 PM

Hi all just to say thanks for all the orders and they have all been posted

Also many thanks to Roger for all the hours of hard work on the shock setups for everyone to use! So far I have heard very good reports about how good the setups are.

Also i have just swoped to a RB5 Vega so will start working on setups as well as soon as i get a set of big bores for the car.

RogerM 20-04-2012 11:28 AM

Nick I will be in touch over the weekend to discuss VEGA big bore setups.

More testing tonight, maybe tomorrow as well ... we aren't standing still on making the big bores quicker around a lap than the small bores .... for me they already are, significantly so!!

Honeybadger 30-04-2012 10:39 AM

So which way are you meant to mount the pistons in the shocks?

Tapered side up or down?

RogerM 30-04-2012 11:24 AM

tapered side down :)

Honeybadger 30-04-2012 11:41 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RogerM (Post 649765)
tapered side down :)

Thanks Roger, I'm on it now. I'll get the Laser out for a blast in a bit. :thumbsup:

Nick 16-06-2012 09:57 AM

Hi all just to say all orders have been posted out yesterday :thumbsup:

RogerM 16-06-2012 03:12 PM

Just a note to say that in the brief spell of warmer weather we got I found both cars were a bit too soft on the oils quoted above and ended up +5wt in the front of both and +2.5wt in the rear of both.
Still sure I have the best piston combination in there for both cars.

Going to do a few runs with the DB1 on small bores to get a feel of Kev's set up then will start working on a big bore set up for her.

tomtom 16-06-2012 06:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RogerM (Post 665242)
Going to do a few runs with the DB1 on small bores to get a feel of Kev's set up then will start working on a big bore set up for her.


You got me interested ! :drool:

RogerM 27-06-2012 12:25 PM

Some extra testing has suggested that a higher pack setup works better on the 2wd cars (still happy with the Lazer setup once the oil grades where upped a little when the weather warmed up).
Will post details of the revised setups once they have been properly tested by a couple of different drivers.

Work has begun on the DB1 setup.

Rebelrc 28-06-2012 08:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RogerM (Post 649765)
tapered side down :)

Makes absolutely no difference at all, fact!

RogerM 29-06-2012 11:21 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rebelrc (Post 669398)
Makes absolutely no difference at all, fact!

Absolutely incorrect I am affriad ... that is how they work, all about the change in effective section along the length of the hole. It's a very common flow biasing tool used in many different engineering genres.

Rebelrc 30-06-2012 06:24 AM

Sorry Roger I ment
It makes no difference at all to pack and rebound speeds:)

RogerM 01-07-2012 07:35 AM

No it does make a difference.

The area of the hole on the flat face (which is of course circular) is smaller than the area of the hole on the tapered side (which is oval). Although a little over simplified you can think of it as a change in speed of the fluid as it passes through the hole.

From big hole area to small hole area the fluid will have to speed up (same volume displaced, smaller area for it to flow through at the exit so it has to travel faster to get through in the same time). This change in fluid speed changes the point at which the shock 'packs up' relative to the other direction.

With the tapper down effectively the pack point on the compression stroke is lower / earlier than that on the return stroke. This is also exaggerated by the fact that in use the return stroke will always be slower / lower energy than the compression stroke due to the balance of forces (this is also the reason you can't accurately gauge the pack point by bouncing the car on the table ... you need to drive it as you will never bounce it as fast as the suspension tries to move when hitting a bump on track).

Tapered pistons mean that you can get a faster return Vs. bump stroke thus allowing you to use more pack than you could normally without slowing the direction change down as a parallel bore piston would ... with is why I say for our tracks tapered pistons are essential to get the performance out of the big bore shocks.

There are lots of design considerations around pistons (even in our relatively crude rc shocks), they are far from a flat disc with a few holes in :)

Nick's pistons transform the Kyosho big bores, try the same piston sizes in straight and tapered back to back on the same track, same day same car .... I have a couple of piston related things I am working on which I will be talking to Nick about soon ;)

Battle_axe 01-07-2012 11:23 AM

surely though this all works the wrong way arround you want really fast up travel in the shock and to be able to control the rebound. in reall life the last thing you want is any kind of pack or lock up i think the mip pistons are the propper way to do this

RogerM 01-07-2012 06:36 PM

We control roll AND big jump landings with our shocks and the cars use quite a large percentage of their suspension travel just in roll in a normal corner ... if they returned slowly it would take an age for the car to return to center let alone start rolling the other way.

Have a think about what we are trying to achieve with our very simple shocks and how our surfaces and track designs affect the car differently to say a 1:1 rally car.

discostu 01-07-2012 07:34 PM

We get what you mean roger however I would say the shape of the piston is forcing more oil around the piston rather than though a very slightly oval hole and this is why they seem to rebound quicker. Ive also done some back to back piston runs they both produced pretty much the same lap times but the tapperd IMO feel less consistant.

I would say don't waist your money on tapperd pistons unless your are at the top of the time sheets where those drivers can really tell the difference.

Neal 11-07-2013 06:03 PM

Hi Nick,

can i please order a tapered pistons set (4 pieces) for 1/10th kyosho big bore shocks?
with 4 holes of 1,3 mm each please..

can u please pm me? your mailbox is full...........

danmurphy 12-07-2013 06:30 AM

Also trying to get in touch with Nick for some Kyosho big bore tapered pistons but his message inbox is full :(


All times are GMT. The time now is 12:40 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
oOple.com